You forgot to say that we have whole families living in tiny boxes, sometimes 10 people or more. Plus, the shacks were built on occupied land, without permission from the city hall. No one has ownership of their land and to the eyes of the law they are just invaders.

There’s no infrastructure too. Most of the time, the sewage is discharged in natura in rivers close by. There is no transportation, as no kind of public transport can cross those narrow “streets”.

And you seem to completely ignore – or perhaps you’re just too naive – the fact that our ONE THOUSAND shanty towns are controlled by gangs with heavy weapons hence my city is one of the most violent in the world.

You say “don’t destroy it, develop it”, and I respectfully disagree by saying TEAR IT DOWN, BUILD DECENT HOUSES AND LET PEOPLE LIVE IN GOOD CONDITIONS (as you probably do, while typing this kind of nonsense in the comfort of a first world house…).

Can I ask how you made the maps and how did you illustrate the movement patter by dots? Did you put the dots one by one manually or did you use any software. TNX

You can have crowded buses between Panjim and Vasco (in the Indian state of Goa with 1.6 million people) and have smooth jostling free journeys in a city of 14 million.

The thing with Tokyo was that it allowed existing spatial uses (building on small agricultual plots, using old village organizational principles, presence of shrines in neighbourhoods) to evolve and modernize through a creative, more plastic and adaptive use of civic amenities. It used the winding tracks of the railways to create a system of transport that changed the way we think of circularity and linearity in urban spaces.

This could well be one of the many reasons why the city may appear calm and relaxed. There are less jams for sure. It could be GPS or it could be the way the messy road networks allow for more route discoveries and navigation then the simplistic, 90 degree, grided road patterns of Manhattan – simply designed for jams!

And yes of course – districts designated to be business and entertainment ones produce a different kind of experience then those that emerge from a more diffused notion of it – tempered by totally different philosophies of what makes for entertainment. Dense neighbourhoods, tiny bars and winding roads open up the imagination very differently than the designated enclaves of pleasure and entertainment on 42nd street – which many find jaded.

Cities are subjective entities. We all will perceive them differently. However – its vital to see how much diversity there is in the way uses of space express themselves in cities around the world. And they are of course meant to produce different experiences. Why should cities be experienced in the same way? Why not look at the special qualities?

Tokyo indeed share many qualities of other Asian cities. The problem is many Asian cities also experienced colonialism and denied their own logic. Tokyo, through the fate of history – escaped certain categories – native town v/s white town for one! What emerged were both similarities and differences with the larger Asian fabric for sure.

Lets continue with the discussion!

I just returned from Tokyo this morning, my first and a long awaited trip. My impression for Tokyo as one of the most populous urban regions in the world was more about density than anything else. I had read, seen pictures and heard about the rush in Tokyo, people pushers in Subways and crowded lanes.

Surprisingly, I failed to experience this density and the City seemed to be extremely calm and quiet. That does not mean it was slow or lacked energy. It seemed to be running on a number of super-efficient systems where both man and machine were performing to perfection. I never saw roads packed with cars, or trains where people couldnt board or human jams at intersections. Business/ entertainment districts such as Shinjuku or Roppongi were nowhere close to an experience in New York, Mumbai, Manila, Hong Kong or Jakarta during the office rush hours.

Many are intrigued by my unique observations about Tokyo. I wonder what would you have to say?

Planet of Slums takes an easy position. Too easy.